Birds and insects on x-band radar

Bird and insect migrations occupy overlapping reflectivities (or echo strengths) on weather radar. For this and other reasons, distinguishing migrations dominated by birds from those dominated by insects is challenging for most weather radars. However, smaller radars capable of providing detailed information on the flight behavior of individual birds and insects can distinguish between these two target types.

The images below depict signal strength (or echo strength) as a function of slant range from the radar. In collecting these data, the radar is not rotating but pointed at a fixed azimuth and elevation. Birds and insects pass through this stationary beam producing echo peaks at varying ranges.


Birds

Bird image


A red highlighted region of the echo signal shown above is animated to the left. The animation shows how the echo changes over 9 seconds as a flap-coasting migrant moves along the stationary beam away from the radar. Notice how the bird's echo signal peak varies considerably in strength as the bird flaps, then becomes relatively steady as the bird coasts. The bird target dissappears as it moves out of the beam. By comparison, ground clutter appears as a non-moving peak of relatively constant echo strength throughout the duration of this sample. The wing beat rate of this bird can be estimated by stepping through the animation and noting the difference in time between 2 succeeding high peaks during a period of flapping flight. For example, adjacent wing beats occur at 4.88 and 4.97 seconds, a difference of 0.09 seconds. We then calculate wing beat rate as 1/period = 1/0.09 = 11 wing beats per second - definitely not an insect.


Insects

Insect image

A red highlighted region of the echo signal shown above is animated to the left. The animation shows how the echo changes over 8 seconds as an insect moves along the stationary beam away from the radar. Unlike the bird depicted above, the insects's echo signal decreases relatively monotonically in strength during flight as it slowly moves out of the beam (left to right). Ground clutter appears as a non-moving peak of relatively constant echo strength throughout the duration of this sample.


The University of Southern Mississippi. Last modified: 15 July, 2004 4:52 PM . Questions for Webmaster
College of Science and Technology
URL: http://www.usm.edu/biology/x-band/index.html
AA/EOE/ADAI